Legal Dictionary of Pakistan

XYY-chromosome defense

Criminal law. defense, usu. asserted as the basis for an insan ity plea, whereby a male defendant argues that his criminal behavior is due to the genetic abnormality of having an extra Y chromosome which causes him to have uncontrollable aggressive impulses. ( Most courts have rejected this defense because its scientific foundations are uncertain. See INSANITY DEFENSE. - Also termed XYY defense "As one commentator has suggested ... 'an attorney defending an XYY individual will be required to call upon both a geneticist and a psychiatrist to give expert testimony. The geneticist's role would be to testify with respect to the individual's genetic structure, any distinguishing characteristics which are relevant to an insanity defense, and the result of family studies designated to determine the influence of genetics and environment on the development of this individual. The psychiatrist's testimony would focus upon the defendant's mental capacity or condition.' But in the absence of-sound medical support for an XYY defense, courts are understandably unsympathetic to defense efforts to obtain such expert testimony." Wayne R. LaFave & Austin W. Scott, Jr., Criminal Law § 4.8, at 380 (2d ed. 1986) (quoting Note, 57 Geo. L.J. 892, 902-03 (1969)).