← Back to Sitemap Directory

PCRLJ 2023 Directory

Index of all citations and judgments published in PCRLJ during 2023.

Found 212 case citations for PCRLJ 2023

▸ 2023 P Cr FAHEEM---Petitioner Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDUL NASIR---Petitioner Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD RAFIQUE and another---Petitioners Versus DIRECTOR GENERAL, FEDERAL INVESTIGATION AGENCY, ISLAMABAD and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr The STATE through Advocate-General, ICT---Petitioner Versus ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE and 2 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr ISMAIL IJAZ---Petitioner Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD MUSAWAR ABBASI---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr ARSHAD MEHMOOD and others---Petitioners Versus SPECIAL JUDGE-I, ANTI-TERRORISM COURT, ISLAMABAD and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD IBRAR KHAN---Appellant Versus Mian MUHAMMAD RAMZAN and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr JUNAID QAMAR---Petitioner Versus SESSIONS JUDGE, WEST ISLAMABAD and 2 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD BILAL SHEIKH---Applicant Versus ACCOUNTABILITY COURT NO. I, ISLAMABAD and 5 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD AZAM KHAN SWATI---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr Mst. VEERA---Petitioner Versus JONATHAN and 2 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr ABBAS KHAN---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr INTIZAR HUSSAIN and another---Petitioners Versus AMJAD HUSSAIN and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr KHURRAM IMTIAZ---Petitioner Versus ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE, ISLAMABAD and 3 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD SHAHBAZ SHABEER---Petitioner Versus ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE and 5 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD SHAH---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr JAVAD KHAN---Petitioner Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr AMMAD YOUSAF---Petitioner Versus GHULAM MURTAZA CHANDIO and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD SHAHZAD KHALIQ---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 PCr ADAM AMIN CHAUDHRY and another---Petitioners Versus NATIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY BUREAU (NAB) ISLAMABAD through Chairman and 29 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr AMIR SAJJAD and others---Appellants Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr GUL TAJ---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr AKHUANZADA SHAHID ALI QURESHI---Petitioner Versus JUDGE SPECIAL COURT (OFFENCES IN BANKS), ISLAMABAD and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr SUDHEER through Senior Superintendent, Central Prison, Hyderabad---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDUL MANAN---Applicant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr STATE/ANTI-NARCOTICS FORCE through Assistant Director and another---Applicants Versus IMDAD ALI and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr FAIZ MOHAMMED alias FAIZ---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ZAFAR and another---Applicants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr JAHANZEB KHAN---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ALI JAN---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MAIRAJUDDIN---Applicant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr I.G. GENERAL TRADING (LLC) and another---Petitioners Versus PROVINCE OF SINDH through Secretary, Government of Sindh, Land Utilization Department,
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDUL KHALIQUE---Applicant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDUL MAJEED---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr GHULAM ABBAS MAGSI---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDUL WAHID---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MASHOOQUE---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr HYDER ALI---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr AMEER BUX---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ASMATULLAH PATHAN---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr AHSAN MAHAR and others---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr DANISH and others---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr SAJJAD ALI and others---Petitioners Versus ABDUL RAUF and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr FAREED AHMED and another---Applicants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDUL WAHEED---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUNAWAR ALI---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr GHULAM ALI alias LAMI and another---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr BASIT ALI---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr HUMAYUN MIRZA---Petitioner Versus STATION HOUSE OFFICER, POLICE STATION SHAHPUR SADAR,
▸ 2023 P Cr AHMED---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr SANAULLAH and others---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr FAIZ MUHAMMAD PITAFI and another---Applicants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr Shaikh SHAHID UMAR---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr SAEED GUL and another---Applicants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD ALI JAVED---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr SADAR alias SADARUDDIN and another---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr KHAMISO---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr GULLAB alias ARO---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ROSHAN ALI and another---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr FAZAL MEHMOOD---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ASIM MURTAZA KHAN---Petitioner Versus The STATE through Chairman, NAB, Islamabad---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr BARKAT ALI---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr WAZEER---Appellant Versus GHULAM QADIR alias GHULAM MUHAMMAD and 4 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr SARDAR BUX---Applicant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDUL QADIR---Applicant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD NADEEM---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD HASHIM ISLAMI---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr Syed MUHAMMAD ADNAN---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr NASEEM---Applicant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD YASEEN alias MAMA GADDI---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr SALAHUDDIN and 3 others---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ALI SHER LEGHARI and another---Applicants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr UMAIR AZAD---Applicant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD AYUB---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr TAJ MOHAMMAD and 23 others---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr JAN MUHAMMAD alias KHAFAI PAHORE and another---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ALI AKBAR and 2 others---Applicants Versus The STATE through D.P.G. Sukkur and 3 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUKHTIAR ALI---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr DILAWAR---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr RIZWAN RIAZ and another---Applicants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD RAHEEL---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr Mst. SUNILA MUSHTAQ---Appellant Versus BABAR HUSSAIN and 7 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr Syed ABDUL MANAN and another---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ALTAF AHMAD MAKHDOOM---Petitioner Versus INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE, PUNJAB and 9 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr BABU KHAN---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD YAR and 4 others---Petitioners Versus GHULAM HAIDER and 2 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr AHMAD ALI and another---Petitioners Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr SHOUKAT ALI---Petitioner Versus I.G. PRISONS and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD NASIR---Petitioner Versus JUSTICE OF PEACE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD GHAZANFAR NAVEED---Petitioner Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr Malik AZMAT ULLAH---Petitioner Versus FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN through Secretary, Ministry of Interior
▸ 2023 P Cr NIRMA SHAHZADI---Petitioner Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr UMAIR ISHTIAQ---Petitioner Versus STATION HOUSE OFFICER and 5 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MADIHA AMMAD---Petitioner Versus The STATE through Prosecutor General Punjab and 9 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD IQBAL and another---Appellants Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr Mrs. SAIRA FATIMA SADOZAI---Petitioner Versus D.I.G. INVESTIGATION and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr Dr. SHAFI-UR-REHMAN AFRIDI---Petitioner Versus The STATE and 2 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUTEEN UR REHMAN and others---Petitioners Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr AMIR HAYAT---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr Rao GHULAM MUSTAFA---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr Malik USAMA BIN TAHIR AWAN---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD RAEES---Appellant Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr NIAZ KHAN---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr SAJJAD ALI---Petitioner Versus ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE, MANDI BAHAUDDIN and 12 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr AFZAL KHAN and others---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD RAMZAN---Petitioner Versus SPECIAL JUDGE ANTI-TERRORISM COURT-III, LAHORE and 5 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr ABID FAROOQ---Petitioner Versus FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN through Secretary Ministry of Interior and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr JAVED IQBAL---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr ANJUM LATIF---Appellant Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD SARWAR---Petitioner Versus NATIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY BUREAU through Chairman and 3 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr TAUHEED ABBAS---Appellant Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD ZAMAN---Petitioner Versus ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr HASWAR SHAH and others---Appellants Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD NAVEED---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr AKBAR alias MOHSIN---Appellant Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD AKRAM alias AKRI and another---Appellants Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr UZMA ADIL KHAN and others---Petitioners Versus FEDERAL INVESTIGATION AGENCY through Director General, Islamabad
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD SHAHZAD and others---Appellants Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDUL HAMID---Appellant Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD ZUBAIR and another---Appellants Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD RAMZAN---Petitioner Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD ALAM KHILJI and others---Petitioners Versus JUDGE ACCOUNTABILITY COURT and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr GHULAM YASIN and others---Appellants Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr ABU BAKAR---Appellant Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr NASIR ALI RAJA alias ASIF---Appellant Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr KHALID MEHMOOD---Appellant Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr KHALID SAFDAR MAKHDOOM---Petitioner Versus GOVERNMENT OF THE PUNJAB through Secretary Specialized Healthcare and Medical Education Department and 8 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr NUMAN alias NOMI and others---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ARSHAD ALI---Appellant Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr SAQIB RAMZAN---Appellant Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr FIDA HUSSAIN and others---Appellants Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr KABEER AKBAR---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr RAFIQUE AHMED---Petitioner Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MAKHDOOMZADI GAUHAR BANO QURESHI---Petitioner Versus PROVINCE OF PUNJAB through Chief Secretary, Punjab and others-- Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr AFZAL NAZIR---Appellant Versus COLLECTORATE, TAXATION AND ANTI-SMUGGLING, LAHORE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD LATIF---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr SHAHZEB---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD FAROOQ---Appellant Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr AZIZ KHAN---Appellant Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD AFZAL---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr SAJID---Appellant Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr RIAZ MUHAMMAD---Appellant Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr Mufti KIFAYAT ULLAH---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr NAVEED DAUD---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr HARIS---Appellant Versus ZAHOOR KHAN and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr SHAH NAWAZ KHAN---Appellant Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr NOOR REHMAN and another---Appellants Versus The STATE through Additional Advocate General, Darul Qaza, Swat and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr ZAHID KHAN---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr FARMAN HUSSAIN---Petitioner Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD RAHAT FAREED---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr SHAFIQ-UR-REHMAN and another---Petitioners Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr FAKHAR ZAMAN---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD AZAM---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr YASIR KHAN and another---Petitioners Versus The STATE through Advocate-General, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Peshawar
▸ 2023 P Cr ZULFIQAR ADDITIONAL SHO, POLICE STATION JAMRUD AT JAMRUD DISTRICT KHYBER and 2 others---Petitioners Versus ZULFAT SHAH and 2 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD IKRAM---Petitioner Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr JUMA KHAN---Appellant Versus ZARIF and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr NOOR-UR-REHMAN---Appellant Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr IJAZ AHMAD and others---Appellant Versus The STATE through A.A.G. and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr ANWAR BADSHAH---Appellant Versus STATE through Additional Advocate General and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr ZAHIREEN and another---Appellants Versus The STATE through A.A.G. and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD FARHAN TARIQ---Appellant Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr JANAT GUL---Appellant Versus MUHAMMAD SAEED and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr IMTIAZ ALI KHAN---Appellant Versus The STATE through Advocate-General, Bannu Bench---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr GUL SHAH PEERI---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr ZEESHAN HAFEEZ---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr NOOR HABIB SHAH---Appellant Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD ZAHOOR UL ISLAM---Petitioner Versus CONVENING AUTHORITIES AIR FORCE COMMODORE, PESHAWAR and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD EJAZ SAEED---Petitioner Versus The STATE and 2 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr SAJJAD AHMED---Petitioner Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr Sheikh ZAHOOR AHMED---Petitioner Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr SHERAZ KHAN---Appellant Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr LUTF UR REHMAN and another---Appellants Versus The STATE and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr Mst. SHAKIRA---Appellant Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr HAROON---Appellant Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr AJMAL and 5 others---Petitioners Versus The STATE through Advocate General, Government of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa,
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDUL NABI and others---Appellants Versus The STATE through Deputy Prosecutor General (NAB), Balochistan Quetta---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr JUMA KHAN---Petitioner Versus DIRECTOR GENERAL NATIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY BUREAU BALOCHISTAN, QUETTA and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDUL QADEEM SHAH---Appellant Versus ABDUL WADOOD and another---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr RAZA MUHAMMAD---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MIRA BUKHSH---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD ANWAR---Petitioner Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr DOST MUHAMMAD---Petitioner Versus Malik SHAH MUHAMMAD and 6 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDULLAH---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MIR HAMMAL---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr Mir AHMED---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr NASRULLAH alias MOMIN and another---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr NABI KHAN---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDUL REHMAN and another---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr FAZUL and 2 others---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDUL GHAFFAR and others---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MEER MUHAMMAD---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr SARDAR MUHAMMAD---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ABDUL GHAFFAR---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr NOOR ZAMAN---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr SHAHZAD KHAN and another---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr KHALIQ DAD---Appellant Versus NADIR KHAN and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD ISMAIL and another---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr The STATE through Additional Attorney General---Appellant Versus MUHAMMAD JUMA---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr IHSAN ALI---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr SAIFULLAH---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr RAMZAN and others---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD NAWAZ---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUHAMMAD AZEEM and others---Appellants Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr ALI SHER---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr NAZEER AHMED---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr NIAZ MUHAMMAD and others---Appellants Versus The STATE and others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr TAWEEZ KHAN---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr MUSHTAQ AHMED---Appellant Versus The STATE---Respondent
▸ 2023 P Cr NAZIM SHAHEEN and 10 others---Appellants Versus ADALAT KHAN and 8 others---Respondents
▸ 2023 P Cr TASLEEM ZAHEEN---Appellant Versus MUHAMMAD NAJEEB and another---Respondents