Statutory construction
Statutory construction legal meaning, translation and judicial precedents.
Meaning & Judicial Interpretation: (اردو مفہوم اور قانونی تشریح)
Words "and" & "or" were interchangeable and the word "and" could be construed as "or" and vice versa; if such change was necessary to effectuate obvious intention of Legislature or statutory rules framer
Rule of avoidance of double taxation was merely a rule of construction, therefore, it ceased to have application when the Legislature expressly enacted a law which resulted in double taxation of the same income, however, in the absence of clear provisions stipulating double or multiple levies, the courts must lean in favour of avoiding double taxation
While there could be double taxation if the Legislature had distinctly and expressly enacted it, however, in the absence of such an enactment, where there were general words of taxation, then the Court had to interpret the provisions in a manner where they could not be so interpreted as to tax the subject twice over same
In absence of any impediment specifically created in the Constitution of a country or the Legislative enactment itself, there was a desirability or need to otherwise to avoid such double liability therefore the court, unless there was clear and specific mandate of law in favour of multiple levies, in construing general statutory provisions, must lean in favour of an interpretation as to avoid double taxation.
"Statutory construction", Pakistan Law Portal, available at: https://paklawportal.com/words-terms-maxims/124945166
Precedents & Case Laws citing "Statutory construction"
1993 S C M R 1320
YUSUF ALI KHAN, BARRISTER‑AT‑LAW‑‑‑Petitioner Versus Messrs HONGKONG AND SHANGHAI BANKING CORPORATION and another‑‑‑Respondents
Court: Supreme Court of Pakistan1990 C L C 1587
NAWAB‑‑‑Petitioner Versus ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER (R), LAHORE DIVISION,
Court: Lahore2024 S C M R 1806
KHALID alias MUHAMMAD KHALID and others — Petitioners Versus COLLECTOR OF CUSTOMS (ADJUDICATION), CUSTOM HOUSE, LAHORE and others — Respondents
Court: Supreme Court of Pakistan2003 P T D (Trib
N/A
Court: Income‑tax Appellate Tribunal Pakistan2005 Y L R 455
THE ZARGHOON TOWN through its Nazim‑‑‑Petitioner Versus GOVERNMENT OF BALOCHISTAN through Chief Secretary and others‑‑‑Respondents
Court: Quetta2019 P T D 1862
ABDUL SALAM Versus FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN through Secretary and 3 others
Court: Lahore High Court1992 M L D 212
MIAN GHULAM NABI‑‑‑‑Petitioner Versus ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER/REGISTRATION OFFICER (RURAL) and another‑‑‑‑Respondents
Court: Lahore1997 C L C 679
Messrs MALAH RICE MILLS, JACOBABAD and others‑‑‑Petitioners Versus PRESIDING OFFICER, BANKING TRIBUNAL, LARKANA and others‑‑‑Respondents
Court: Karachi2002 C L C 54
Master SAID‑‑‑Petitioner Versus Ch. IFTIKHAR HUSSAIN, DISTRICT JUDGE, JHANG and others‑‑‑Respondents
Court: Lahore2015 M L D 995
NATIONAL SILK AND RAYON MILLS — Petitioner Versus FEDERATION OF PAKISTAN and 4 others — Respondents
Court: Lahore