1981 PLP 522 (CLC)
T. R. ARTHUR‑Appellant Versus ALEX ROBERT DAVID‑Respondent
| Citation | 1981 PLP 522 (CLC) |
| Forum / Court | Karachi |
| Bench Members | Z. C. Valliani, J |
| Parties | T. R. ARTHUR‑Appellant Versus ALEX ROBERT DAVID‑Respondent |
| Primary Law | (a) Evidence Act (I of 1872) |
Q1: What are the key laws and sections cited in 1981 PLP 522 (CLC)?
This judgment primarily cites: (a) Evidence Act (I of 1872) as referenced in Pakistani case law index.
Q2: Which judicial bench decided the case 1981 PLP 522 (CLC)?
The case was heard and decided by the Karachi bench comprising: Z. C. Valliani, J.
Q3: What is the official citation format for this judgment on Pakistan Law Portal?
Cite this legal precedent as: 1981 PLP 522 (CLC) (T. R. ARTHUR‑Appellant Versus ALEX ROBERT DAVID‑Respondent). Read the full summary and cross-referenced laws free on Pakistan Law Portal.
Laws Cited
Representation
- Sami Ahmed for Appellant.
- A. F. Af. Mokarim for Respondent.
- Dates of hearing : 26th and 27th November 1980.
Headnotes / Summary
S. 47 read with S. 67‑Documents‑Proof‑Respondent proving documents only through his deposition on oath and not producing their executants to prove them‑‑Appellant raising no objection at time of production and exhibition of such document‑Held, lower Court erred in relying on such documents. Muhammad Yuruf v. S. M. Ayab P L D 1973 S C 160 rel. (b) Civil Procedure Code (V of 19o8)‑ S. 11‑Res judicata‑Former suit dismissed for non‑prosecution and not on merits‑Former decision, held, did not constitute res judicata. [Res judicata]. (c) Evidence Act (I of 1872)‑ S. 92‑‑Oral evidence, exclusion of‑Respondent by oral evidence not trying at all to show any variation in terms and conditions of lease agreements‑Such oral evidence, held, admissible.‑[Evidence]. Riaz Ali v. Shabbir Ahmad Khan 1971 S C M R 598 distinguished. Firm Kesla Mal Nand Kishore v, Cooper Allen & Co. A I R 1936 All. 717 ; Kunja Bahari Das v. Raman Behari Das A I R 1937 Cal. 619; Champaran Jain v. Sripati Nath Das A I R 1938 Cal. 430 and Athar Ali v. Abdul Taher Bhuiyan P L D 1961 Dacca 349 rel.
Judgment & Decree
(b) Civil Procedure Code (V of 19o8)‑ S. 11‑Res judicata‑Former suit dismissed for non‑prosecution and not on merits‑Former decision, held, did not constitute res judicata. [Res judicata]. (c) Evidence Act (I of 1872)‑ S. 92‑‑Oral evidence, exclusion of‑Respondent by oral evidence not trying at all to show any variation in terms and conditions of lease agreements‑Such oral evidence, held, admissible.‑[Evidence]. Riaz Ali v. Shabbir Ahmad Khan 1971 S C M R 598 distinguished. Firm Kesla Mal Nand Kishore v, Cooper Allen & Co. A I R 1936 All. 717 ; Kunja Bahari Das v. Raman Behari Das A I R 1937 Cal. 619; Champaran Jain v. Sripati Nath Das A I R 1938 Cal. 430 and Athar Ali v. Abdul Taher Bhuiyan P L D 1961 Dacca 349 rel. Sami Ahmed for Appellant. A. F. Af. Mokarim for Respondent. Dates of hearing : 26th and 27th November 1980.