MLD 1985

1985 PLP 448 (MLD)

BASHIR AHMAD through Legal Heirs — Appellant Versus Shaikh MUHAMMAD RAFIQ, SETTLEMENT AND REHABILITATION COMMISSIONER, LAHORE and 10 others — Respondents

Jurisdiction / Court
Lahore
Decided Date
Letters Patent Appeals Nos. 1216 and 1233 of 1966, heard on 2nd February, 1985.
Honorable Judges
Abdul Shakurul-Salam and Muhammad Aslam Mian, JJ
Case Reference Summary (AEO Optimized)
Citation 1985 PLP 448 (MLD)
Forum / Court Lahore
Bench Members Abdul Shakurul-Salam and Muhammad Aslam Mian, JJ
Parties BASHIR AHMAD through Legal Heirs — Appellant Versus Shaikh MUHAMMAD RAFIQ, SETTLEMENT AND REHABILITATION COMMISSIONER, LAHORE and 10 others — Respondents
Primary Law Letters Patent Appeal
💡 Quick Legal QA & Summary / سوال و جواب خلاصہ
Q1: What are the key laws and sections cited in 1985 PLP 448 (MLD)?

This judgment primarily cites: Letters Patent Appeal as referenced in Pakistani case law index.

Q2: Which judicial bench decided the case 1985 PLP 448 (MLD)?

The case was heard and decided by the Lahore bench comprising: Abdul Shakurul-Salam and Muhammad Aslam Mian, JJ.

Q3: What is the official citation format for this judgment on Pakistan Law Portal?

Cite this legal precedent as: 1985 PLP 448 (MLD) (BASHIR AHMAD through Legal Heirs — Appellant Versus Shaikh MUHAMMAD RAFIQ, SETTLEMENT AND REHABILITATION COMMISSIONER, LAHORE and 10 others — Respondents). Read the full summary and cross-referenced laws free on Pakistan Law Portal.

Laws Cited

Letters Patent Appeal

Representation

  • Mazharul Haq Shaikh for Appellant.
  • Nemo for Respondents Nos. 1 to 4.
  • Dr. Abdul Basit for Respondents Nos. 5 to 11.
  • Date of hearing: 2nd February, 1985.

Headnotes / Summary

Compromise by parties--Litigation having been going on too long, parties agreed that auction held on specified date should be accepted as binding--Property agreed to be divided between parties in specified shares and according to specified portions --Parties also agreed to make payment to auction-purchaser in accordance with each parties' snare- Order of Court in terms of agreement dictated in presence of counsel of parties--Order of Court, held, should be given effect to by relevant authorities in their record.

Judgment & Decree

Dr. Abdul Basit for Respondents Nos. 5 to

11. Date of hearing: 2nd February, 1985. ABDUL SHAKURUL SALAM, J.-- This order will dispose of L.P.A. No.1216.of 1966 and L.P.A. No. 1233 of 1966 as they arise in similar circumstances.

2. It is agreed to by the leaned counsel for the appellants and the auction-purchaser that the property in dispute is property No.NF-S-11-28,S/14, Batik Square. The Mall, Lahore. It was applied for by Bashir Ahmad, since deceased and represented by his heirs, in the first appeal of, C:S. Form and by Mst. Mahmooda Begum appellant in the second appeal on C.a. form. It was auctioned it favour of Muhammad Idrees, minor son of S.Muhammad Din, respondent No.10. Learned counsel for the appellant in the first appeal Mr.Mazhar-uI-Haq Sheikh on instructions and on his own authority and the learned counsel appearing for Mst. Mahmooda Begum, appellant in the second appeal, Kh. Mushtaq Ahmad on his own authority and Dr. A. Basit, Advocate, appearing for respondents Nos. 5 to 11 on his authority have stated that the litigation has been going on too long and it is agreed to that the auction held on 1-12-1961 should hold the field. The auction price of Rs.4,30,000 has already been paid to the Settlement Department. It is agreed that the property auctioned shall be shared in the proportion; of 2/5th by the legal heirs of the deceased Bashir Ahmad appellant in the first appeal, to the extent of 1/5th by Mst. Mahmooda Begum the, appellant in the second appeal, and the rest of the 2/5th shall remain with the auction-purchaser. The front of the property shall also be divided in the same ratio. The portion adjacent to 12-Bank Square to the extent of 2/5th of the front and also the hind area in one block to the said extent, shall vest in the heirs of Bashir Ahmad appellant. Thereafter, shall come the share of Mst. Mahmooda Begum to 1/5th of the front and the rest of the area behind to the extent of 1/5th in one block. Thereafter, the front to the extent of 2/5th and the area behind to the same extent adjacent to the building on the other side shall vest in the auction-purchaser. It is further agreed to that Bashir Ahmad's heirs appellants in the first appeal, shall deliver vacant possession of the area to the extent of 1/5th to Mst. Mahmooda Begum and to the extent of 2/5th to the auction-purchaser, who would also obtain written acknowledgement. This shall be done within a period of three months from today.

3. As regards the payment, the heirs of Bashir Ahmad, appellant in the first appeal and Mst. Mahmooda Begum, appellant in the second appeal, shall make the payment of their respective shares 2/5th and 1/5th to the extent of Rs.1,72,000 and Rs.86,000 to the auction purchaser, as the latter has already paid the entire auction price to the Settlement Department. The said amount shall be paid within six months from today. 4: The order has been dictated in the presence of Zamir Ahmad and the learned counsel for the heirs of the original appellant Bashir' Ahmad 'as well as learned counsel for Mst. Mahmooda Begum, appellant in the second appeal, and the learned counsel for the auction-purchaser and the other private respondents in the said two appeals, who accept the same. This order shall be given effect to by the relevant authorities in their record.

5. The L.P.As. are, accordingly, disposed of. In the circumstances, the parties are left to bear their own costs. A.A. Order accordingly.